Cigarettes as a “Plant-Based Alternative” to Vapes: Behind a Viral Claim About Gen Z
Key takeaways
- Polymarket’s post echoes a New York Post article built entirely on testimonials posted on social media;
- Among them, a young Californian claims her fractured hand healed after she switched from vaping to smoking;
- The doctors quoted at the end of the article point out that most smoking-related disease comes from combustion;
- The data contradict the claim: in the United States, smoking among high school students remains at a historic low, and in France, daily smoking among 18- to 29-year-olds fell from 29% to 18% between 2021 and 2024.
A post, an article, some videos
On 12 November 2026, Polymarket, an online prediction market on current events, published a post on X that has since been viewed more than 7 million times:
JUST IN: Gen Z reportedly increasingly turning to cigarettes as a “plant-based alternative” to vapes.
— Polymarket (@Polymarket) November 12, 2026
While the post cites no source, it actually echoes a New York Post article published two days earlier under the headline Gen Z fueling tobacco sales as wild claims cigarettes are ‘healthier’ than vaping go viral: ‘plant-based alternative’. In that article, the phrase “plant-based alternative” is attributed to an unnamed young TikTok user.
The entire article is built around social media: posts, threads and videos by young members of Gen Z, generally defined as people born between 1997 and 2012. The least that can be said is that one hopes not every member of this generation thinks the same way.
In its February 2026 report, based on an analysis of some 2,500 studies, the French health safety agency ANSES concluded that e-cigarettes are less risky than tobacco for all the effects assessed, while not being risk-free. The difference lies in combustion: according to Santé publique France, cigarette smoke contains more than 7,000 substances, at least 70 of which are carcinogenic, as well as carbon monoxide. Without combustion, vapour contains far fewer: ANSES measured aldehyde levels 80% to almost 100% lower than in cigarette smoke.
For example, a young Californian, whose TikTok video was viewed 4.2 million times, claims she regained her energy and saw her fractured hand heal after switching from vaping to smoking. Her story is worth telling in detail. After fracturing her hand and seeing no improvement after six weeks, her doctor explained that nicotine constricts blood vessels and slows down healing. She then decided to throw away her vapes and, whenever a nicotine craving hit, to light a cigarette instead of using a patch or following a doctor-approved plan to quit.
“At my next checkup, I had significant healing,” she recalls. “I’m not saying cigarettes are healthy, but people’s relationship with cigarettes is more sustainable than with a vape.” She adds that after giving up vaping and going back to tobacco, her brain fog lifted and her energy returned.
Her doctor is not wrong: nicotine does constrict blood vessels. But according to a systematic review published in Annals of Surgery, its own effect on the healing process, like that of nicotine replacement therapy, appears to be marginal. Smoking, on the other hand, does delay bone healing: a meta-analysis of 122 studies published in EClinicalMedicine shows that smokers have significantly higher rates of nonunion and deep infection. Finally, a hand fracture usually takes six to eight weeks to heal, according to St George’s Hospital in London. The improvement seen at her next checkup may therefore simply reflect the normal healing time.
According to her, smoking even has another advantage. “Vaping is isolating — everyone sits in corners with their own device,” she explains. “Cigarettes bring people together. Someone steps onto the porch, others follow, and suddenly you’re having real conversations without phones.” Apparently, it is impossible to gather in the same way while vaping.
The article also quotes a vlogger who says cigarettes are “spiritually healthy”. And one of her fans agrees: for this person, a cigarette break is a chance to “touch grass”.
The idea that cigarettes are more “natural” or less dangerous than vapes is gaining ground. In the United States, the share of adults who consider vaping more harmful than smoking rose from 2.8% in 2012 to 30.4% in 2022, according to a study published in Nicotine & Tobacco Research, which we mentioned when it came out. Its authors point out that this perception is associated with a higher likelihood of switching from vaping to smoking. In the United Kingdom, 19% of people who tried to quit vaping using a specific method turned to cigarettes, according to the 2026 Smokefree GB survey. As for tobacco being “natural”, it makes no difference: burning any plant, natural or not, produces tar, carbon monoxide and a host of toxic substances, including carcinogens. It is combustion that makes smoke dangerous, not the origin of what is burning.
While some of these claims and comments are amusing, others reveal a genuine misunderstanding of the dangers of smoking. A 22-year-old New Yorker explains, for instance, that smoking takes more effort, since you have to buy your cigarettes, light them and smoke them. The wording may be a little clumsy, but it is easy to understand what he means. The problem lies mostly in the reasoning that follows: according to him, all this effort means that people smoke less often than they vape, which is therefore better for their health.
Smoking a little is not smoking safely. According to a meta-analysis of 141 cohort studies published in the BMJ, men who smoke just one cigarette a day have 46% of the excess risk of coronary heart disease of a 20-a-day smoker, and 41% of the excess risk of stroke. For women, the figures are 31% and 34%. Risk is therefore not proportional to the number of cigarettes, and the authors conclude that there is no safe level of smoking for cardiovascular disease. What matters is not frequency but exposure to the products of combustion, which is precisely what vaping avoids.
Fortunately, the article ends with several comments from health professionals.
Dr Carol Eisenstat, a board-certified physician and medical director of Line Eraser M.D. in New Jersey, says it is “concerning” to present smoking as healthier than vaping, before pointing out that while nicotine is responsible for addiction, tobacco combustion carries a heavy burden of disease that is not found with vaping.
Her comments are echoed by Dr Sylvie Stacy, a physician with a master’s degree in public health and a specialist in addiction medicine, who explains that “the vast majority of disease and death from smoking comes from combustion”, and that “it certainly doesn’t make sense to switch to cigarettes to lessen those risks.”
Let us hope the New York Post is on TikTok and that Gen Z will one day read this article.
What the numbers say
That leaves the underlying question: is Gen Z smoking more? The latest available data show that it is not, quite the opposite. In the United States, the share of 10th and 12th graders who smoked in the past month went from 2.6% in 2023 to 2% in 2024, then 2.2% in 2025, with no significant change, according to a study published in The Lancet Regional Health – Americas. Among 18- to 24-year-olds, only 3.4% smoked in 2024, compared with 14.8% who vaped, according to an analysis published in NEJM Evidence.
In France, according to Santé publique France’s health barometer, the share of daily smokers among 18- to 29-year-olds fell from 29% in 2021 to 18% in 2024. And among high school students, the French Monitoring Centre for Drugs and Drug Addiction (OFDT) recorded a threefold drop in daily smoking between 2018 and 2024.










