- On November 9, 2026, the European Commission’s Regulatory Scrutiny Board (RSB) issued a negative opinion on the impact assessment for the revision of the TPD and the Tobacco Advertising Directive.
- The Board does not judge policy objectives: it checks the quality of the analysis on which the Commission bases its legislative proposals.
- Its opinion matters: without a positive opinion, a proposal accompanied by an impact assessment cannot normally be put forward for adoption by the Commissioners, unless the College takes a political decision.
- The Board reportedly questioned the proportionality of the planned measures, the evidence for a “gateway effect” from vaping to smoking and the legal basis for EU-wide bans.
- The TPD3 proposal, expected by the end of 2026, could slip to 2027.
A New Negative Opinion
The news was first reported on November 12, 2026, by the Brussels newsletter Europe.Table. The Regulatory Scrutiny Board (RSB) adopted a negative opinion on the impact assessment on November 9. The assessment is meant to accompany the revision of the Tobacco Products Directive (TPD) and the Tobacco Advertising Directive (TAD).
This is the second setback of its kind for the file in less than a year. On December 12, 2025, the same Board had already issued a negative opinion on the evaluation of the current TPD. It criticised the document in particular for failing to define how the rules apply to new nicotine products and for ignoring coherence with the Tobacco Taxation Directive. The Commission nevertheless published its evaluation report on April 2, 2026: a report that completely overlooked the very principle of tobacco harm reduction.
A Commission spokesperson said the institution was now working to present this important proposal as soon as possible, without giving a timetable.
What Is the RSB?
The RSB was set up by a decision of the Commission President on May 19, 2015, as part of the Commission’s “Better Regulation” agenda. It replaced the Impact Assessment Board, in place since 2006, which had examined the impact assessment for the current TPD in 2012.
According to the Commission’s official page, the Board has nine members: a chair, four senior Commission officials and four external experts.
All of them work full-time for the Board, with no other policy responsibilities, for a non-renewable three-year term. The RSB acts independently of the directorates-general that draft legislation and of any other EU institution.
Quality Control
The RSB examines every impact assessment accompanying new Commission initiatives, as well as a selection of evaluations of existing legislation. Its role is to check the quality of the preparatory work: are the problems well defined, the options compared, the impacts quantified, the evidence solid?
The Board does not rule on the political merits of a measure. It decides neither on initiatives nor on their objectives: that is for the College of Commissioners. Its opinions are of three types: positive, positive with reservations, or negative.
An Opinion That Matters
For an impact assessment, the RSB’s opinion is not a mere formality. Under the Commission’s rules, a positive opinion, possibly with reservations, is required before an initiative can be put forward for adoption. After a negative opinion, the directorate-general must revise its work and resubmit it.
If the Board issues a second negative opinion on the same assessment, the initiative cannot move forward without a political decision: it is then up to the College of Commissioners to decide. The RSB reiterated this in 2026 in its second negative opinion on the draft European Innovation Act: its opinion is “as a rule final,” and the lead service can only seek political guidance.
This lock is not absolute, however. In 2021, the draft Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive received a first negative opinion on May 7, then a second on November 26. Although the file was delayed by almost a year, the Commission still presented its proposal on February 23, 2022.
For an evaluation, by contrast, a negative opinion does not prevent the report from being published. This explains why the TPD evaluation report could come out in April despite the December 2025 opinion.
In the case of TPD3, this is the first negative opinion on the impact assessment itself. DG SANTE must now revise its document and resubmit it to the Board.
What the Board Criticised
The RSB’s opinion is not public: the Commission publishes these opinions together with the proposal, once it has been adopted. Its content is therefore known only through the press. According to several sources, the Board questioned:
- the proportionality of the planned measures;
- the lack of a specific analysis of their fiscal consequences;
- an inadequate analysis of their socio-economic consequences;
- the evidence put forward for a “gateway effect” from e-cigarettes to cigarettes;
- the legal basis for bans decided at EU level, in an area where competences remain largely national.
What It Means for Vaping
The last two points go to the heart of the debate on the future TPD. The gateway effect is an argument regularly put forward by Health Commissioner Olivér Várhelyi, for which 23 European experts took him to task in a letter to Ursula von der Leyen. The gateway effect holds that using an e-cigarette increases the risk of smoking later on, a hypothesis contradicted by scientific data from around the world. In France, for example, between 2018 and 2024, daily smoking among high school students fell threefold, while their daily vaping more than doubled.
The legal basis issue concerns the most radical measures demanded on October 6 by eight Member States, including France: a market freeze on new nicotine products, a general flavour ban and the option for each country to ban nicotine pouches outright.
The criticism of the fiscal consequences relates to the Tobacco Taxation Directive, which is also stuck in the Council since Malta blocked it on November 9, 2026. The Commission will therefore have to show how the two texts fit together.
Finally, the timetable is likely to suffer. Expected in the last quarter of 2026, the TPD revision proposal could now slip to 2027.
A Board Under Scrutiny
The RSB is not without its critics. In 2023, an NGO specialising in lobbying transparency filed a complaint with the European Ombudsman, arguing that the Board was exposed to the influence of interest representatives. In her September 2024 decision, the Ombudsman found no objective evidence of undue influence. She nevertheless recommended that Board members avoid meeting individual interest representatives, to preserve the appearance of their independence.
In the tobacco file, the RSB’s opinions have already become an argument. On November 3, a coalition of 201 businesses and trade associations, including tobacconists, wholesalers and farmers, asked Ursula von der Leyen to rethink her approach to revising the directives. It cited, among other things, the Board’s criticisms.
The European Commission has not given up on TPD3, but it will have to better substantiate its proposals. For vaping, the stakes are high: an internal Board is now demanding solid evidence for the gateway effect and a clear legal basis for EU-wide bans.






